Pizzeria, located in Coraopolis, PA, has established itself as a local legend, treasured by many long-time residents. This pizza parlor invokes nostalgia, with customers like Joe Ventimiglio recalling flavors that transport them back to childhood. Pizzeria offers a perfect balance of dough, sauce, and cheese, earning accolades for its well-crafted pies. Reviewers rave about the flavorful sauce, which stands apart from competitors, and the generous application of cheese that brings each pizza to life. The crust strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, enhancing the overall experience, as noted by Mike Rhodes. His first visit underscored the innovative baking technique, where toppings like pepperoni and sausage meld beautifully under the cheese. Longtime fans, including Elayne Johnson and Michael Coyle, appreciate the consistent quality and warm service that creates a welcoming atmosphere. Each visit feels like a homecoming, with the staff's kindness and the comforting familiarity of the flavors. Pizzeria is undeniably a gem in Coraopolis, where classic recipes and a passion for pizza combine to create experiences worth savoring again and again. Whether you’re revisiting childhood memories or discovering it for the first time, a slice from Pizzeria guarantees satisfaction.
Amenities and More
Service options
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Amenities
No toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Children
Good for kids
Photos
Reviews For Pizzeria
Joe Ventimiglio
May 30,2025
While I haven't eaten pizza here in decades, I recently had the opportunity and stopped by. This was the ONE and ONLY Pizzeria in Coraopolis when I was a small boy - and after experiencing it again - IT STILL IS! Tastes like I remembered; tastes like I hoped it would. Dough, sauce and cheese never so right. Very nice owner keeping the memory alive. I hope to return.
Mike Rhodes
May 26,2025
First time! Me and wifey stop here. Order 2 cheese 2 pepperoni 2 sausage. We get to the car and open the box the pieces had 1 pepperoni on them. I said "they could put a little more on". Then I bit 1 "WOW" it was superb. The pepperoni and sausage was baked under the cheese with some on top to identify them. The crust was crispy and soft and easy to enjoy, a simple tomato sauce complimented the slice.
Michael Coyle
May 24,2025
This is literally the best pizza in the area, at least for me. They've been there since before I was born and they have never once disappointed me. The sauce is excellent, as is everything else. I look forward to when I can pick some up.
nicole17200
Apr 14,2025
A classic gem of coraopolis. Great slices! Get sausage.
Elayne Johnson
Apr 9,2025
I've been coming here since I was a young girl and I truly love the pizza sauce and the generous mounds of cheese that they put on your pizza. The flavor is different from any other pizza I've tasted. The sauce is more richer in flavor.Very delicious Also the service staff our Always KIND. and Courteous to their customers. The prices are right for me .I'd recommend this place anytime for delicious pizza. Try it ....I guarantee after you've tasted the pizza ? You'll always return for more. Keep up the great food and great service.
Casey Robinson
Mar 15,2025
Old school Pizzeria. Cash only. Delicious square cut pizza. I usually order NY Style but would take this pizza over any NY style. Toppings are under the cheese. Highly recommend this place if you're in the area.
Cassie W
Feb 28,2025
The. Best. Pizza. Anywhere. Hands down. Definite family favorite... pepperoni for hubby, straight cheese for the youngest son, and sausage with green peppers for the oldest son and myself. We always order unbaked so we can bake it at home together for an awesome family pizza night. An absolute staple for the area. We local!
Colin Gnibus
Feb 21,2025
Local pizza shop been in biz since 1959 which i stumbled upon while working in the area . OUTSTANDING in every way. From the service I received to the quality of the ingredients and is definitely one of the very best I have tried . The owner was extremely nice and informative ,Order the sausage its truly amazing and all from local area. Almost zero grease!! U can order by the slice as well. I ordered 2 plain, 2 sausage, & 2 w green peppers and sausage . Was so good that I literally came back and ordered 2 pre baked specials for my family 15 min later . Each special came w 16 pieces . I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND STOPPING you will not be disappointed As you can see in the photos my son felt the same .. lol
Reviews For Pizzeria